How to Make Yogurt–Troubleshooting
April 6, 2012
I have been trying to include more fermented foods in our diet recently. I have read about and personally experienced the benefits of consuming probiotics and so was motivated to learn how to include more fermented foods in our family’s diet. However, I have felt a little lost in setting out to grow bacteria in my kitchen. It goes against so much of my cooking experience and I certainly do not want to do anything in ignorance that could make my family sick. With further learning, I felt more confident that I could make yogurt safely. I read Tonya’s article about how to make yogurt and it sounded so simple. How could I go wrong?
I learned that yogurt making is a very simple process, and yet I found many ways to ruin it. I am hoping that you all can learn from my mistakes.
My first mistake was using a starter straight from the refrigerator to the yogurt. I learned the hard way–cold starter makes lumpy yogurt. I would love to know the science behind why that is. But in the meantime, for smoother yogurt, don’t forget to place your starter on the counter before you start cooking. I have been told that using a package of yogurt starter gives more consistent results than using plain yogurt. I am far too new at yogurt making to speak to consistency myself. In the hope of increasing my chances for success, I purchased a package of yogurt culture locally at the Breadroot Co-op.
I also learned that homemade yogurt is much thinner than store yogurt. I have found two solutions for this. You can either strain off some of the liquid with a fine mesh strainer once the yogurt is set. Or you can add in a little powdered milk while you are heating the milk for the yogurt. Both have worked well for me.
The worst problem I encountered was a bad taste in my yogurt. Even though I watched the milk closely as I heated it, my yogurt tasted scalded. I eventually created a homemade double boiler and finally made good tasting yogurt. I found a dish that fit inside my pan with handles that set on the pan rim to hold it up. It took longer to heat the milk, but I didn’t have to watch it as closely and it solved my final yogurt-making challenge.
Give yogurt making a try. It actually is easy—once you know how.



If you enjoy baked potatoes but don’t want to run your oven for an hour plus, the potato bag is for you. Using this bag you can have microwaved potatoes that are moist and flavorful in just ten minutes. You scrub a few potatoes, wrap them in a paper towel, stick them in your potato bag, and the microwave does the rest. And they will retain the nutrients that are lost when potatoes are boiled and the cooking water discarded.
Trudy’s sun-dried tomatoes may be purchased at the Heritage Farmers Market, 3500 West Chicago Street, in Rapid City. Of this recipe Trudy says, “Hopefully this will inspire creativity in the cooks out there! Bon Appetit!”
