Beef Processing, Inc., the company that bills itself as “the world’s leading producer of lean beef processed from fresh trimmings,” has come under fire for its product now known as ‘pink slime.’ This product has been added to the ground beef used in school lunch programs, served in restaurants, and sold in supermarkets. As the result of customer pressure, McDonald’s, Taco Bell, Burger King, and Safeway have decided not to use the product, and school lunch programs may now opt out.
Let’s dig down a bit. Saving boneless beef trimmings might be a good thing to do, a sign of frugality, of best use of resources. Those little chunks of muscle and connective tissue, instead of going for dog food, become human food. Over the centuries and across cultures people have saved many animal parts and made them into sausage, head cheese, haggis, blood pudding, liverwurst, and other tasty edibles. Are ground up beef trimmings any different?
Well, there are risks with any finely chopped animal food not eaten immediately. Once raw animal parts are chopped up into tiny pieces, they will spoil quickly. That’s because there is so much surface area on which microbes take up residence and extract the nutrients so easily available. And some of these microbes may cause human disease. Then we call them pathogens.
Because packinghouses are perfect places for pathogens to thrive, the U.S. Department of Agriculture inspects meats that cross state lines and the packing plants that process them. One concern is the presence of E. coli, bacteria that live in the intestines of mammals, including humans, and whose presence suggests possible pathogen contamination. These bacteria, living as they do in animal guts, thrive in acidic environments. As a precaution against pathogens, Beef Processing, Inc. exposes all ground up beef trimmings to ammonia. The gas combines with the water in the meat to form ammonium hydroxide, a potent base that is lethal to E. coli.
Questions remain. Since the human body produces a significant amount of ammonia every day, does the small amount added to the meat create a health risk? Could there be other pathogens in the meat that are not killed by ammonia? Should the addition of ammonia be on the label? Has media hype changed what could be acceptable food into something disgusting, icky, and unsellable? How does this product compare with hot dogs, sausage, bacon, and lunchmeats with their added nitrites, which can turn into cancer-causing nitrosamines?
Industrial production of meat is a complex and risky and mostly hidden business. And it’s the hidden part that is of concern. What about animal abuse? What about worker mistreatment? What about processing plants that don’t follow the rules? What about the inadequacy of USDA inspections?
For myself I opt for an open meat production process. Here in West River we are fortunate to have 34 Ranch, Black Hills Milk, the 777 Ranch, Wild Idea Buffalo Company, and Dee Holmberg, all producing high quality meat. We know that some animals from these producers are grass finished and some are grain finished and the producer will tell you which is which. We know that the animals are healthy and do not get treated with growth hormones, antibiotics, or other chemicals. Most important, these farmers and ranchers really care about their animals. We can talk to them and ask them about every step of their operations. We have visited their farms and ranches. So this is our DLFN advice: Buy local from people you know.